A guide to an awkward but necessary conversation starter.
This blog post was originally written for The Green Fix, a newsletter by Cass Hebron (a Channels member) and was published with permission.
We need to talk.
About the elephant in the room. About that awkward silence at the family reunion and that Tweet you wanted to send but worried was ‘too much.’
Source: Joel Pett
Talking about the climate crisis is awkward, particularly when the people you’re talking to don’t want to hear it. The doom-and-gloom headlines are too horrible to bear, the solutions too abstract. Who would want to spend more time thinking about it?
I used to worry that I sounded repetitive or preachy bringing up sustainability so often. I cared more about keeping things pleasant and inoffensive. And the result was… nothing. No impact, no change.
We need to get used to having difficult conversations about the climate. The more we talk about it, the more it becomes socially acceptable to talk about it, and ultimately - to act on it.
And it doesn’t have to be depressing. A conversation about the climate crisis should also be a conversation about the solutions that are out there, and about the world that could be: a greener, fairer and healthier world. Those aren’t buzzwords or idealistic visions, they are tangible and achievable things - if we get everyone on board.
Why does it matter how I talk about the climate crisis?
The language we use impacts how we think about topics, and can present different versions of the same event.
Most of us, including me, were taught about the climate crisis in school, usually featuring a polar bear on a melting iceberg. It was called ‘climate change’ or ‘global warming’ - phrases that have also been used by climate deniers to downplay the seriousness of the situation (think of that Twitter troll that keeps saying the climate has always been ‘changing’).
In 2017, The Guardian officially changed its style guide to replace ‘climate change’ with ‘climate crisis,’ while governments declared ‘climate emergency.’ This is a deliberate way to show how urgent the problem is.
I know it’s a crisis. But how can I get my family/postman/cat take me seriously?
Talking about the climate can be awkward. Who has found a way to bring up the IPCC report in a Zoom party without killing the vibe? Being an environmentalist has also had a host of unwelcome attached stereotypes over the years: treehugger, ‘mung-bean munching eco-freak,’ or doomsdayer.
But the differences between social groups are outweighed by our similarities when it comes to climate change. As a whole, people of all political views agree that the climate crisis is a serious issue:
Results from a study by Climate Outreach, which grouped UK participants into 7 segments depending on their political beliefs.
What studies like these find is that differences between us come from different perspectives on how to address the crisis and who should be doing it - which could fill a whole book in itself. But when it comes to getting people around you to listen, the common values are where we need to start.
But we have completely different values!
Our values drive our behaviour. This values chart by PIRC shows which values tend to occur together: as in, if you value tradition highly, you’re more likely to also value security than, say, hedonism.
Values chart by PIRC
People who value things with an external benefit (like altruism and concern for others) are more likely to care about climate change. The trick is to find the overlap between those values for the outside world, and the values of the person you’re talking to.
For example, freedom and security are likely to be shared among people of very different political and social beliefs - so making connections between climate action and a secure future for local lands, the economy and/or wellbeing would be a good place to start.
[For a helpful handbook on identifying values, check out Eco.Talks]
Dos and Don’ts
Tap into the values of the person you’re talking to (see.. literally the previous paragraph).
Make it personal What does climate change mean for them in the here-and-now? How is it already impacting local areas, the air quality of your city, the health of your neighbours?
Share your story Why do you care about the climate crisis? Share how you became interested, and why it matters so much to you. This can have far more impact than reciting scientific statistics.
Provide solutions Show people the potential benefits of taking action. By creating a vision of a world we want - nature restored, better health and wellbeing, green jobs and secure futures - it gives your audience a reason to hope and a reason to act.
Show by doing Sometimes actions speak louder than words. By consistently acting in line with your values, sharing the reasons for your behaviour, and letting your convictions drive your behaviour, you are part of the movement making sustainability a social norm.
Focus on doom-and-gloom headlines When I read about the 6th mass extinction, I don’t feel motivated - I feel powerless. Apocalyptic headlines are likely to drive people away.
Lecture Changing people’s minds means listening to them, their values and concerns. It’s a conversation, not a sermon.
Focus on the numbers Scientific evidence is useful to back up what you’re saying - but you wouldn’t normally talk like a textbook to your friends, so sprinkle the stats in lightly.
Only talk to people who already agree These days it’s easy to exist in a bubble of like-minded people, especially online. But for real change we need to talk to people of different political and social beliefs, and have difficult conversations.
Communications nerds (like me) can check out a more in-depth and technical guide to talking about the climate in an upcoming edition of Tom Moylan’s fantastic newsletter - subscribe to receive it.
So Now What Do I Do?
Check out this interesting study by UK organisation PIRC on how people think about climate justice.
Read Climate Outreach’s handbook on how to have a climate change conversation - and put it to the test!
Climate deniers are rare these days. But just in case, here’s a comprehensive rebuttal of almost every argument against climate change.
TRY SOMETHING NEW
Share Climate Outreach’s video & article on how to encourage positive lifestyle change.
Climate media outlet Grist are holding a climate fiction writing competition asking you to envisage the world in 2200. Closes 12th April, first prize $3000.
Join this free online course on Climate Change Solutions, by the University of Exeter.
CHANGE THE SYSTEM
Join the next Fridays4Future Global Climate Strike on the 19th March!
Organise an event for upcoming Earth Day on the 22nd April.
Pre-register for the UN SDG Global Festival of Action to take part in discussions about real solutions to the climate crisis, inequality and poverty.
Did you enjoy this post? Check out The Green Fix newsletter by Channels member, Cass Hebron and share this blog post!